Advice on software patents and computer implemented inventions.
Patent protection for software related inventions in the UK often depends on how the invention is analysed under the exclusion provisions, and on how its technical contribution is identified and claimed. We advise on computer programs, software patentability and computer implemented inventions, including prosecution strategy where exclusion and technical character are likely to be the central issues.
The key patentability issue
UK law excludes a program for a computer as such, but that phrase has always required interpretation in practice. In Emotional Perception the Supreme Court revisited the structure of the UK approach and concluded that the Aerotel method was unsound, replacing it with the any hardware threshold at the exclusion stage.
That is a major change, but it does not mean every software invention is patentable. The important next question is which features contribute to the technical character of the invention as a whole, because those features are central to the later patentability analysis.
One of the major hurdles to acquiring UK rights has been removed. Two points remain central: the invention must be considered as a whole, and feature interactions must be properly assessed.
Hepworth Browne, on the position after Emotional Perception
Why this matters for software and CIIs
Many commercially important products are mixed inventions, combining software, business logic, data handling and technical processing. That makes invention framing critical, especially where the key issue is whether the relevant features contribute to the technical character of the invention as a whole.
It has practical consequences for drafting and prosecution. If the invention is framed too narrowly, too abstractly, or at the wrong level of generality, the strongest technical interactions may be missed, which weakens both the exclusion and the inventive step arguments.
Areas of support
- Patentability reviews for computer programs and software heavy products
- Claim strategy for computer implemented inventions and mixed inventions
- Advice on technical character, feature interaction and statutory exclusion
- Review of objections based on the computer program exclusion or related software patentability issues
- UK filing strategy where software functionality forms a central part of the invention
Computer programs, ANNs and modern technologies
The judgment broadened the definition of a program for a computer and addressed artificial neural networks directly, while leaving difficult issues for practice. That matters because many modern inventions do not fit neatly into older assumptions about conventional software. Labels alone are not enough: software, AI and technical systems need carefully prepared patent strategy.
For more information, please contact Bruce C. Dearling, Shareholder at Hepworth Browne, at bcd@hepworthbrowne.com.
